Institute for Bioethics & Health Humanities Events

Seminar Series

Upcoming Seminars - All Are Welcome

The Elephant in the Womb: A Bioethics Blueprint for De-extinction using Ectogestation

Department of Bioethics and Health Humanities

Special Guest Lecture

The Elephant in the Womb: A Bioethics
Blueprint 
for De-extinction using Ectogestation

Friday, March 24, 2023

12:00 – 1:00 p.m.

 

Richard B. Gibson, PhD, FHEA
Visiting Scholar
Dept. of Bioethics & Health Humanities
School of Public and Population Health
Elizabeth Chloe Romanis, PhD, FHEA
Assistant Professor
Department of Biolaw
Durham University

Register HERE in advance for the Zoom lecture.
After registering, you will receive a confirmation email.

Attend In-person
UHC 4.108

 

The Mammoth is often considered the poster child for de-extinction – the process of resurrecting extinct species. This perspective technology, however, comes with tremendous bioethical baggage. Unfortunately, much of the ethical discourse around de-extinction focuses on the potential for unintended environmental harms and anxieties about ‘playing God.’ While undoubtedly significant, the focus on these grandiose concerns has come at the expense of exploring de-extinction’s more practical issues. One critical oversight concerns the gestational location of the prospective Mammoth; where will these animals develop from fertilised eggs to fully formed calfs? Many researchers suggest that African elephants can satisfy such gestational requirements, given their proximity to Mammoth biology. However, the risks inherent in elephant pregnancy are already substantial, and adding the uncertainties of cross-species gestation will likely compound such dangers, endangering both surrogate and gestating Mammoth. As an alternative, some have tentatively suggested ectogestation – using artifice to gestate organisms. According to such suggestions, an artificial placenta would undertake the gestational labour rather than developing a Mammoth within an elephant. However, such a proposal’s ethical complexities are unconsidered, and it is an elucidation of such issues to which this paper turns its gaze. It starts by giving an account of the science underpinning de-extinction and, specifically, an overview of how you go from a genetic blueprint to a fully formed Mammoth. The paper then explores ectogestation in two parts: partial and complete. It concludes by arguing that while the former is more realisable than the latter, it is more ethically fraught.

Event Information

The Elephant in the Womb: A Bioethics Blueprint for De-extinction using Ectogestation
, 2023 - -
Add to Calendar:

Event Contacts

Departmental Events

Upcoming Departmental Events - Closed to outside participants

All Previous Events

The Spirit of Asilomar

, 2023 - -

Dr. Campos will explore the resonances and tensions between the famed historical Asilomar (which saw itself as a future-directed event), and contemporary claims for its putative lessons.